Salmond Threatens UK with Debt Default over Scottish Currency Problems

 

The leader of the Scottish National Party (SNP), Alex Salmond, has promoted panic in international markets with the assertion that an independent Scotland would not repay its debt should a formal currency union with the United Kingdom fail.

800px-First_Minister_opens_distillery01

Despite Mr Salmond recently claiming “it’s our pound, and we’re keeping it”, the SNP leader has been under pressure to provide information on an independent Scotland’s currency should a formal agreement with the UK fail.

The leader of the Better Together campaign, Alastair Darling, voiced back in January that a currency union with an independent Scotland seemed “increasingly dead in the water”:

“It appears that the First Minister needs a basic lesson in economics. The UK Pound is a monetary system underwritten entirely by the UK Government. It’s not an asset to be shared like the CD collection after a divorce.

“Keeping the Pound would need a political agreement between what would then be two foreign governments to have a veto on each other’s tax rates, spending plans and borrowing levels. But it is an idea that is increasingly dead in the water. We need to know what Alex Salmond’s Plan B is – will we set up our own currency or will we adopt the Euro?”

In open letters to readers of The Sun, Mr Salmond recently ended the speculation of what a ‘Plan B’ might look like by declaring that such a plan did not exist.

“Plan B implies settling for what’s second best. And neither myself, my colleagues in the SNP, or the wider Yes campaign will ever settle for second best for Scotland.”

The currency question is not one which will go away for Mr Salmond, as it remains a weakness in his proposals for an independent Scotland. However, the SNP leader’s tactics have turned more aggressive in recent days through his commitment of defaulting on Scotland’s debt should he win September’s independence referendum without gaining a formal currency union.

“If Westminster tells us we can’t get a fair share of the Bank of England, a public asset which Scots have helped pay for, then we cannot be expected to pick up a share of the UK’s £1.3trillion debt.”

This tactic places Mr Salmond’s campaign on unfavourable ground: Should Scotland vote Yes at the polls in September – despite knowing that there would be no formal currency union – and default its debt repayments, investors may be very reluctant to consider Scotland as a market for their investments; moreover, should all of the above take place, and Scotland needs to create its own currency from scratch – a time consuming and expensive process – would it be able to borrow in order to do so? And lastly, because Scotland would be seen as a higher risk to investors due to defaulting, future borrowing rates – should it be able to negotiate them – would be far higher than what Scotland currently enjoys as a part of the UK, making life more expensive for its citizens.

It’s not an ideal situation for any new country to find itself in, but I suspect that this announcement is more of a cavalier remark rather than actual policy because Mr Salmond finds himself stuck between a rock and a hard place, and as the referendum looms in the not too distant future, he is running out of options.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Scotland can’t default on its debt repayments because it has no debt. Zero. The Scottish government is currently not allowed to borrow.

    You may argue that there is a moral obligation for the Scottish government to accept a proportion of the UK Government’s debt in the event of independence but I’m certain there is no legal obligation. Refusing to accept someone else’s debt is not a default and seems a pretty reasonable thing to do if they have failed to negotiate a fair split and use of previously shared assets.

    • The “Scottish government” as you refer to it doesn’t currently exist, it is merely a regional parliament. All borrowing by the UK government is on behalf of all of its citizens, any secession is your choice. However, refusal to take your share of liability will entitle the UK to withhold equivalent assets and take no obligation for your desire to enter the EU and other international organisations

  2. It does seem a bit desperate from Salmond. He’s been saying that he would consider ditching the debt for a while, but if he is stepping up his game then he truly does not understand the consequences of his idea. I think Yes voters would quickly resent voting the way they did very quickly

    • His followers lap up that kind of bluster though, its merely for the votes. Even Salmond knows he will hamstring Scotland for a long time if it came to pass…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here